Political Diary
New Delhi, 14 November
2023
SC Raps Governors
TIME FOR SOUL SEARCHING
By Poonam I Kaushish
Whoever said different political
strokes for different political folks was dead on. Specially when it comes to
the high Constitutional office of Governor. Wherein handpicked chamchas do whatever their mai baaps sitting on India’s Raj gaddi want. Governance, after all is one
big nautanki which has turned
democracy on its head. Bend them, break them, who cares if Governor’s office is
in shambles!
The latest lament was
by Supreme Court Monday, which expressed acute displeasure at Governors holding
back Bills in Opposition-ruled States Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Telangana virtually
forcing State Governments to approach for judicial intervention while hearing Punjab
Government accusing Governor Purohit of sitting on seven key Bills including Money
Bills since July. Chief Justice Chandrachud rapped, “This is a serious issue …
Why should Parties be made to approach Supreme Court for Governors to act.”
Stingingly adding, “We
are a democracy in operation since birth of Constitution. These are matters to
be sorted out between Governors and Chief Ministers. We will ensure
Constitution is complied with. Time everybody, including Governors and Chief
Ministers, did a little bit of soul-searching. Governors should not be
oblivious that they are not elected by the people.”
Chimed in Kerala, “Governor
Khan held back crucial Bills, some pending for over two years… When we told him,
he said ‘let us see, we will fight it out’.” Ditto Tamil Nadu which accused
Governor Ravi of positioning himself as “political rival” who had caused “Constitutional
deadlock” by sitting on Bills, neither assenting nor returning them for months
together.
Clearly, Purohit-Mann conflict is a lesson on dangers of appointing
political hatchet men to high offices that call for fairness, uprightness and
adherence to Constitutional values and conventions. Worse, it underscores Centre
and Governors have no intent in rectifying flaws and upholding Constitutional
tenets. Specially, as it comes 6
months after Court intervened for Telangana asking Governor Soundarajan to clear Bills pending since September 2022.
Raising a moot point: Have Governors become a law unto
themselves? Are Legislatures in Opposition-ruled States West Bengal, Punjab, Kerala
and Tamil Nadu at their mercy? Are Governors dabbling in Vice-Chancellors
appointments to State-run universities? Are they absent from official
functions and convening of
Assembly session et al? Are Parties ideologies
becoming touchstones for Constitutional matters? Will this not weaken country’s
federal structure?
Earlier too, Court in a Chief Minister vs Governor
case said, levels of discourse should not degenerate into a “race to the
bottom.” Rajasthan and West Bengal have passed laws against gubernatorial
interference in education. In Rajasthan, Governor faces allegations of
appointing Vice-Chancellors with
RSS-BJP ideology in 7 of 8 universities, 6 of whom are from outside
Rajasthan. Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Stalin asked Assembly Speaker to take
on record only speech prepared by State Government and delete portions added by
Governor.
Instances of Rajyapals ‘misinterpreting’ rule book, drawing his own
conclusions based on delusions so that he and his benefactors at Centre could
rule the roost and clashes with Chief Ministers are aplenty. In Maharashtra
between erstwhile Governor Koshyari- Thackeray, West Bengal
Dhankar-Mamata, Kerala Khan-Pinarayi, Telengana Soundarajan-Chandrashekar
Rao, Tamil Nadu Ravi-Stalin, Delhi Sakena-Kejriwal is par on course.
Be it Congress-BJP,UPA-NDA all are tarred by same brush
whereby each Party which rules the roost at Centre has used, abused and debased this office by reducing
Governors to position of Centre’s kathputli, ever-ready to
destablise the State, if desired by New Delhi. Most have no qualms of
conscience in rubbishing it in personal or Party interest, overlooking
Constitution’s letter and spirit.
Look at the absurdity. A Rajyapal relinquishes office and returns to active
politics, thereby turning conventions of Governor always Governor on its
Constitutional head. Example: Congress’s Shinde relinquished as Maharashtra
Chief Minister November 2004 and was anointed Andhra Governor same day. Two
years later, he re-entered politics as Union Power Minister in Congress-led UPA
I before shifting as Home Minister 2012. Ditto Mizoram BJP Governor
Rajasekharan resigned 2019 to contest Lok Sabha elections from Kerala where Party
wanted to make a dent.
Sadly, in a milieu of you-scratch-my-back-and-I-yours, a gubernatorial
post is no longer decided on whether person is a man of stature known for his
integrity and objectivity, instead it is the perfect lollypop for political
castaways, parting gifts for subservient bureaucrats and convenient posts for
inconvenient rivals, totaling over 60% today. His essential criteria: whether he can be a chamcha .Consequently,
Governor has become a convenient tool of Centre in Opposition-ruled
States where he runs administration by proxy.
Besides, Governor is often used as a lever, facilitator and at worst, surrogate
of Centre’s nefarious designs to install its own Government, at any cost thus
bringing the post into severe disrepute. Accentuating the stress India’s
federal structure is undergoing and the dangers to the country’s democratic
backbone if all sides don’t take a step back and act more judiciously as
none of this is conducive to healthy democracy.
For too long, Governor’s have been perceived to be following the
Centre’s writ, whichever be the Party in Centre. By playing the I-spy game --- petty
politricking, gross interference, open partisanship, sending for files,
summoning Ministers and bureaucrats. To hear, entice, provoke and register
voices of dissent against the State Government to their political patrons in
Delhi. Bluntly, make life hell for Chief Minister at every step.
Supreme Court has held the political aaina with all its pock-marks
and scars. Our netagan must desist from employing their
individual meanness in the name of public good. High time Governors do the job
they are appointed for, being a watch dog and acting in an impartial manner.
Else they need to be dispensed with if they abdicate their Constitutional
obligations and mortgage their souls to the powers-that-be.
Undoubtedly, this rajnitik ring-a-ring-a-roses has to
stop. The BJP needs to realize the sins of
predecessor Governments can
neither absolve nor justify its questionable moves. We need to find a new
method of appointing Governors. Consultation with State Governments might not
be enough as some might be supportive of the Central Government. Instead, Rajya
Sabha should screen prospective candidates who should be interrogated, investigated
and judged on suitability before confirmation.
The President too
should not just act on the aid and advice of her Council of Ministers but could
lay down guidelines wherein she is not misled about a person’s political
affiliations and politics and only those citizens appointed who are politically
neutral.
Arguably, can India
afford to allow persons holding Constitutional offices to accept political
“rewards” for doing at its bidding? No. Ultimately, principles emerge from good
practices not bad ones. Good principles recognise Constitutionalism and
democracy. Time we restore Governor’s office to its old glory. This calls for
fairness, uprightness and adherence to Constitutional values and conventions.
Remember, power
corrupts but also intoxicates and absolute power stimulates grandiose
apparition of immortality. Forgetting that power is evanescent whereby wheels
of fortune will turn and they may be caught beneath its inexorable roll. Our
leaders need to rise above politics and appoint neutral non-political Governors
not yes-men or neta-turned
rajyapal-turned-neta. It is now imperative leaders and Parties who
postulate the Constitution also practice what they preach! ----- INFA
(Copyright,
India News & Feature Alliance)
|