|
|
|
|
|
|
Israel-Hamas War: REVISITING GANDHI & MANDELA, By Dr. D.K. Giri, 27 October 2023 |
|
|
Round The World
New Delhi, 27 October 2023
Israel-Hamas War
REVISITING GANDHI & MANDELA
By Dr. D.K. Giri
(Secretary General, Assn for
Democratic Socialism)
One of the best balanced statements
on Israel-Hamas war I heard was made by Prince Turki Al-Faisal at the Baker
Institute of Public Policy, Huston. He is a Saudi Arabia former Intelligence
Chief and its Ambassador to the United Kingdom and USA. He started his speech
with judicious words that should lead to a strategy for the solution of the
conflict. He said, “All militarily occupied people have right to resist their
occupation, even militarily. But I do not support the military option for
Palestine. I prefer the other option, civil insurrection and disobedience. It
brought down the British empire in India and the Soviet empire in Eastern
Europe.” He qualified his suggestion by explaining that Israel had
overwhelmingly military superiority. The world saw it in the past and can see
it now as Israel dominates and controls Gaza and now pounds it to the pulp.
Unarguably, we should have added the
fall of South African apartheid under the leadership of Nelson Mandela. Without
any shred of doubt, Palestinian problem cannot be resolved by military action
by either side. Even the present Palestine Ambassador to the United Kingdom
stated that non-violence and negotiations are the only way to resolve the
conflict and establish the two-state arrangement. But the terrorists on either
side would not let it happen. Let me hasten to elaborate when I say terror
emanates from either side.
In the past, Israelis have resorted
to terrorism. Historians recall that the origin of Israel state lay in the
violent actions by the Zionist groups like the Irgun and Stern gang such as the
assassination of the UN envoy Count Folke Bernadotte and the bombing of the
King David Hotel in Jerusalem, as well as the killing and terrorising of
Palestinian villagers. Count Folke was a Swedish nobleman and diplomat. He was
selected as the UN first mediator in 1947 for Israel-Palestine issue and
assassinated in the line of duty on 17 September 1948. His aide who was sitting
beside him, French officer Colonel Andre Scrot was also killed. The King David
Hotel was bombed on 22 July 1946 in opposition to Britain’s continued rule of
Palestine.
Notably, Irgun’s leader Menachem
Begin and Stern Gang’s Yitzhak Shamir, both went to become Prime Ministers of
Israel. In current times, critics and observers accuse Israel state of
resorting to violence and terrorising Palestine, running an ‘open air prison’
in Gaza strip and incarcerating Palestinians. Palestinians have been
complaining of cruel oppression in the hands of Israel army, namely, the food,
electricity and water, the basic needs for survival are controlled by Israel
army.
As a matter of fact, the trail of
violence between Israel and Palestine can be traced to the formation of Israel
state in 1947. Sadly, there has been unending chain of violence and counter
violence ever since. How does it stop? Where do we draw a line in history of
the evolution of violence? Is it 1947, when Israel state was created by the
famous Balfour Declaration in 1947, in 1967, post-Arab-Israeli war, or 1973
after the Yom Kippur war or later?
Israel claims that the two-state
solution was offered to Palestine at least five times – Peel Commission
suggestion in 1936, UN arrangement in 1947, after the six-day war in 1967, in
2005 when Yasser Arafat rejected it. Bill Clinton mediating for both parties
said in exasperation that Arafat stayed for 14 days to negotiate but rejected
it altogether with three infamous NOs – No peace with Israel, No recognition of
Israel and No negotiation with Israel. What is more and worse, PLO launched
violent attacks on Israel after the rejection of the accord; and finally, in
2008, which was rejected by the current PLA Chief Mahmoud Abbas.
That said, we are here now. The 7
October terrorist attack on Israel marks the turning point in the
Israel-Palestine relations and conflict. The assault was carried by Hamas. It
is said that Hamas is a jihadist organisation. They do not accept the existence
of a Jewish state. They are not concerned about the territory. They want, like
ISIS, the Islamic suzerainty in the world, regardless of territorial
boundaries. From the available information, Hamas is the second richest terror
organisation in the world. They have a turnover of 1 billion dollar. In an interview, the son of founder of Hamas
revealed the inhuman, barbaric behaviour of Hamas causing Palestine to be the
worst place to live. Instead of digging wells for providing drinking water, Hamas
dig tunnels to smuggle goods for their profit. They torture the Palestinians by
hammering nails to their fingers for their suspected collaboration with
Palestinian army.
In retaliation, Israel is bombing
Gaza and planning for ground operation etc to flush out Hamas. Israel army will
not stop until they eliminate the Hamas’ military capacity to repeat such a
terrorist assault as that of 7 October. In terms of the nature of the violence
that day, it is being compared to the holocaust. However, Israel army will stop
if Hamas surrender unconditionally. Hamas will fight to their death but not
recognise Israel state nor will surrender and apologise for 7 October. The
current state of confrontation and lack of compromise will stalemate the conflict;
or rather will make it worse.
The world is reacting in various
ways. I have discussed their reactions in the preceding column here last week.
Right now, world leaders are asking for a humanitarian pause to allow aid and
explore options like release of the hostages. The European Union’s top diplomat
Josep Borrell has asked for a ceasefire on humanitarian ground. But Israel is
in no mood to listen. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in an interview
that they have made the mistake more than once of listening to the world
opinion which was based on ill-information spread by Leftist media about the
conflict. Israel wants to liberate Palestine from the clutches of Hamas and
eliminate Hamas in the interest of the world peace.
The desirable and workable strategy
as referred to herein the beginning is to shun violence. Hamas, regardless of
what has happened in the past as is acknowledged here, will have to own up the
crime committed on 7 October, and surrender. Terrorism should have no place in
Israel-Palestine conflict. A Gandhian approach of civil disobedience is the way
forward. And taking a leaf out of Nelson Mandela’s book, a Truth and
Reconciliation Commission should be set up consisting of insiders and other
world leaders preferably from India, (land of Gandhi) and South Africa, (land
of Mandela).
Such a Commission should negotiate
the terms of settlement for peaceful and harmonious existence of two states. In
order for this to happen, terrorist organisations like Hamas and Hezbollah have
to be countered internationally. And the second stage should be prevailing upon
Israel state to stop coercion of Palestinians in Gaza or West Bank. Until a
legitimate and genuine political authority is established in Palestine, an
UN-monitored arrangement could be initiated. This practice has happened in
countries which were created out of such conflicts. That is the way to go. ---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature
Alliance)
|
|
EC Directive To Centre: BAN YATRA IN POLL STATES, By Insaf, 28 October 2023 |
|
|
Round
The States
New Delhi, 28 October 2023
EC Directive To Centre
BAN YATRA IN POLL STATES
By Insaf
Three cheers to the Election Commission. It has acted
promptly and decisively on the complaint about “gross misuse of government
machinery”, at the Centre. On Thursday last, it wrote to Cabinet Secretary
Rajiv Gauba not to hold its proposed nation-wide ‘Viksit Bharat Sankalp
Yatra’ from November 20 to highlight Modi-led government’s “achievements”
in the five poll-bound states and in a bypoll constituency in Nagaland.
Congress President Kharge and a retired IAS officer had written to the EC about
a letter circulated on October 18 to all Ministries about the yatra and asking
them to appoint senior officials as “district rath prabharis.” The fact that
‘only achievements of last 9 years are being considered, gives away the fact
this is a transparently political order in the run-up to the 5-state elections
and 2024 general elections,’ wrote Kharge, adding “It’s a clear violation of
Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, which directs that no government
servant shall take part in any political activity.” Nirvachan Sadan responded
saying on October 9 Assembly polls in the 5 States were announced and the Model
Code of Conduct had come into force and under no circumstances the aforesaid
activities be undertaken till December 5, day of counting. The government has
clarified that the yatra will not make a stop in any poll-bound States.
However, a vigil is critical.
* * * *
ED Raids In Rajasthan
The ED has got into top gear in poll-bound Rajasthan,
threatening to severely hit ruling Congress’ campaigning. On Thursday last, it raided
premises of state party president Govind Singh Dotasra and former education
minister in Jaipur and Sikar as part of a money laundering probe into alleged
exam paper leak case and summoned Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot’s Vaibhav son in
a FEMA case in Delhi. Investigating agencies, said party President Kharge have
become the real 'panna pramukh (party workers)’ of BJP. After
Chhattisgarh, ED has also entered the poll campaign in Rajasthan.’ Aptly put,
with Gehlot chipping in urging voters to give a befitting reply as the raids come
days after he announced guarantees for women. Besides Dotasra, whois contesting
from Lacchmangarh seat of Sikar, independent MLA Om Prakash Hudla is under the
scanner. Should raids be put on hold once the polls are announced, needs to be
considered. Importantly, should Election Commission intervene, as Gehlot
demands, for on the face of it summoning, arresting or raiding leaders of
Opposition parties muddies the level-playing field.
* * * *
WB
‘Witch Hunt’
ED action against ministers in West Bengal has Chief
Minister Mamata Banerjee frowning. “If they conduct raids at the residences of
all the leaders, then what is left of the government?” she said, perhaps in
jest, but reason to worry. On Thursday last, the ED arrested forest minister
Jyoti Priya Mallick in connection with an alleged case of corruption in
rationing distribution, when he was minister of food and supply. The arrest
followed searches at his home in Salt Lake, Kolkata and he declared himself to
be a “victim of a grave conspiracy”. His leader said the raids went ahead even
though ‘there was no proof of wrongdoing’. Recall last year minister of
education Partha Chatterjee and his assistant were arrested in a teacher
recruitment scandal; Anubrata Mondal, Mamata’s close aide and Birbhum leader
was detained viz livestock smuggling case; and TMC general secretary and
Mamata’s nephew Abhishek Banerjee has been frequently questioned over
corruption charges. At a press conference didi said TMC leaders and
ministers were being harassed just after Durga Puja, and “Is this the way the
country will be run? How many more will you send to jail? Send everyone to
jail, even then, you will not get votes.” While she may be right, she needs to
set her house in order, sooner than later.
* * * *
Mizoram Rebuff
BJP should have little hope in Mizoram. Chief Minister
Zoramthanga has made it amply clear that he shall not share the stage with
Prime Minister Modi when he comes to campaign in the State, around month-end. “The
people of Mizoram are all Christians. When the people of Manipur (Meities)
burned hundreds of churches in Manipur, they were (Mizos) totally against that
kind of idea. To have sympathy with the BJP at this time will be a big minus
point for my party,” Zoramthanga told BBC News in an interview on Monday last.
His advice: it will be better if the PM comes alone and he shares the platform
by himself, and I take the stage separately by myself.” Interestingly, while
his MNF is a part of BJP-led NE Democratic Alliance and an ally of NDA at the
Centre, the party doesn’t work with the BJP. He explains this is because MNF is
totally against the Congress and doesn’t want to be part of any alliance led by
it. Indeed, BJP has totally failed in Manipur and with thousands of refugees
coming to Mizoram, the MNF has to look after its vote bank. Zoramthanga insists
that it is the responsibility of the Centre to restore peace in Manipur so that
people can go back to their native state. Till then, his government is taking
care of the relief camps with no aid from New Delhi. Perhaps, the BJP and Modi
may do well if there is a change in strategy. For if it makes no inroads into
Mizoram, it could have an impact on other States. Better to be safe than
sorry!
* * * *
TN Face-off Gets Worse
The DMK government-Governor face-off gets nastier. With
a Molotov cocktail, (petrol bomb) lobbed by a man, out on bail, in front of Raj
Bhavan’s main gate in Chennai on Wednesday last has the Governor’s office
seeing red. It alleged there have been incidents of public threats to Governor
Ravi’s life but a “studied indifference” by state police to the matter has
vitiated his security.” In a complaint to Chennai Police Commissioner, it also
alleged verbal attacks and threats were “mostly by leaders and workers of DMK and
its allies in their public meetings and through their social media.” And these,
are “intended to overawe the Governor and restrain him in discharging his
Constitutional duties. However, complaints lodged with the police have been
inconsequential due to police inaction.” No FIR has been lodged with the police
“instead trivialised serious incidents into minor offences with no worthwhile
follow-up.” The Opposition parties too condemned the ‘attack’ and criticised Stalin
government over ‘deterioration’ of law and order. Guess, there’s more than
meets the eye. ---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)
|
|
EC Directive To Centre: BAN YATRA IN POLL STATES, By Insaf, 28 October 2023 |
|
|
Round
The States
New Delhi, 28 October 2023
EC Directive To Centre
BAN YATRA IN POLL STATES
By Insaf
Three cheers to the Election Commission. It has acted
promptly and decisively on the complaint about “gross misuse of government
machinery”, at the Centre. On Thursday last, it wrote to Cabinet Secretary
Rajiv Gauba not to hold its proposed nation-wide ‘Viksit Bharat Sankalp
Yatra’ from November 20 to highlight Modi-led government’s “achievements”
in the five poll-bound states and in a bypoll constituency in Nagaland.
Congress President Kharge and a retired IAS officer had written to the EC about
a letter circulated on October 18 to all Ministries about the yatra and asking
them to appoint senior officials as “district rath prabharis.” The fact that
‘only achievements of last 9 years are being considered, gives away the fact
this is a transparently political order in the run-up to the 5-state elections
and 2024 general elections,’ wrote Kharge, adding “It’s a clear violation of
Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, which directs that no government
servant shall take part in any political activity.” Nirvachan Sadan responded
saying on October 9 Assembly polls in the 5 States were announced and the Model
Code of Conduct had come into force and under no circumstances the aforesaid
activities be undertaken till December 5, day of counting. The government has
clarified that the yatra will not make a stop in any poll-bound States.
However, a vigil is critical.
* * * *
ED Raids In Rajasthan
The ED has got into top gear in poll-bound Rajasthan,
threatening to severely hit ruling Congress’ campaigning. On Thursday last, it raided
premises of state party president Govind Singh Dotasra and former education
minister in Jaipur and Sikar as part of a money laundering probe into alleged
exam paper leak case and summoned Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot’s Vaibhav son in
a FEMA case in Delhi. Investigating agencies, said party President Kharge have
become the real 'panna pramukh (party workers)’ of BJP. After
Chhattisgarh, ED has also entered the poll campaign in Rajasthan.’ Aptly put,
with Gehlot chipping in urging voters to give a befitting reply as the raids come
days after he announced guarantees for women. Besides Dotasra, whois contesting
from Lacchmangarh seat of Sikar, independent MLA Om Prakash Hudla is under the
scanner. Should raids be put on hold once the polls are announced, needs to be
considered. Importantly, should Election Commission intervene, as Gehlot
demands, for on the face of it summoning, arresting or raiding leaders of
Opposition parties muddies the level-playing field.
* * * *
WB
‘Witch Hunt’
ED action against ministers in West Bengal has Chief
Minister Mamata Banerjee frowning. “If they conduct raids at the residences of
all the leaders, then what is left of the government?” she said, perhaps in
jest, but reason to worry. On Thursday last, the ED arrested forest minister
Jyoti Priya Mallick in connection with an alleged case of corruption in
rationing distribution, when he was minister of food and supply. The arrest
followed searches at his home in Salt Lake, Kolkata and he declared himself to
be a “victim of a grave conspiracy”. His leader said the raids went ahead even
though ‘there was no proof of wrongdoing’. Recall last year minister of
education Partha Chatterjee and his assistant were arrested in a teacher
recruitment scandal; Anubrata Mondal, Mamata’s close aide and Birbhum leader
was detained viz livestock smuggling case; and TMC general secretary and
Mamata’s nephew Abhishek Banerjee has been frequently questioned over
corruption charges. At a press conference didi said TMC leaders and
ministers were being harassed just after Durga Puja, and “Is this the way the
country will be run? How many more will you send to jail? Send everyone to
jail, even then, you will not get votes.” While she may be right, she needs to
set her house in order, sooner than later.
* * * *
Mizoram Rebuff
BJP should have little hope in Mizoram. Chief Minister
Zoramthanga has made it amply clear that he shall not share the stage with
Prime Minister Modi when he comes to campaign in the State, around month-end. “The
people of Mizoram are all Christians. When the people of Manipur (Meities)
burned hundreds of churches in Manipur, they were (Mizos) totally against that
kind of idea. To have sympathy with the BJP at this time will be a big minus
point for my party,” Zoramthanga told BBC News in an interview on Monday last.
His advice: it will be better if the PM comes alone and he shares the platform
by himself, and I take the stage separately by myself.” Interestingly, while
his MNF is a part of BJP-led NE Democratic Alliance and an ally of NDA at the
Centre, the party doesn’t work with the BJP. He explains this is because MNF is
totally against the Congress and doesn’t want to be part of any alliance led by
it. Indeed, BJP has totally failed in Manipur and with thousands of refugees
coming to Mizoram, the MNF has to look after its vote bank. Zoramthanga insists
that it is the responsibility of the Centre to restore peace in Manipur so that
people can go back to their native state. Till then, his government is taking
care of the relief camps with no aid from New Delhi. Perhaps, the BJP and Modi
may do well if there is a change in strategy. For if it makes no inroads into
Mizoram, it could have an impact on other States. Better to be safe than
sorry!
* * * *
TN Face-off Gets Worse
The DMK government-Governor face-off gets nastier. With
a Molotov cocktail, (petrol bomb) lobbed by a man, out on bail, in front of Raj
Bhavan’s main gate in Chennai on Wednesday last has the Governor’s office
seeing red. It alleged there have been incidents of public threats to Governor
Ravi’s life but a “studied indifference” by state police to the matter has
vitiated his security.” In a complaint to Chennai Police Commissioner, it also
alleged verbal attacks and threats were “mostly by leaders and workers of DMK and
its allies in their public meetings and through their social media.” And these,
are “intended to overawe the Governor and restrain him in discharging his
Constitutional duties. However, complaints lodged with the police have been
inconsequential due to police inaction.” No FIR has been lodged with the police
“instead trivialised serious incidents into minor offences with no worthwhile
follow-up.” The Opposition parties too condemned the ‘attack’ and criticised Stalin
government over ‘deterioration’ of law and order. Guess, there’s more than
meets the eye. ---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)
|
|
The People’s Right To Information, By Inder Jit, 26 October 2023 |
|
|
REWIND
New Delhi, 26 October
2023
The People’s Right To Information
By Inder Jit
(Released on 7 August 1984)
Ignorance continues to abound in
regard to Parliament, its constitution, practices, procedures and privileges.
Thirty-four years as a sovereign democratic Republic seem to have failed to
inform and educate our leaders and public adequately. Even members of
Parliament have of late spoken in astonishing terms. Not a few inside
Parliament and outside have described the current session of the Lok Sabha as “the
last session of Parliament.” True, the present Lok Sabha is now approaching the
close of its five-year term meet for its winter session in November. (Contrary
to reports, no firm decision has yet been taken about the date of the next
general election. Mrs Gandhi, it appears, prefers to play it by the ear.) But
the Lok Sabha is not Parliament, notwithstanding the fact that it is directly
elected. Parliament is also not the two Houses -- the Lok Sabha and the Rajya
Sabha. Parliament, according to the Constitution, consists of three elements:
the President, the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha. No single entity, by itself,
is Parliament.
Equally, the basic concept of a
parliamentary form of Government is still not understood, even among our
parliamentarians. The system provides for an orderly form of government by
discussion and debate. As Leo Amery wrote in Thoughts on the Constitution, “the
main task of Parliament is still what it was when first summoned, not to
legislate or govern but to secure full discussion and ventilation of all
matters.” Parliament is essentially a critical forum or, as described by Lloyd
George, “the sounding board of the nation” which derives its influence from its
ability to speak to and to speak for the people. Yet, thanks to an unfortunate
failure of leadership on both sides of the two Houses --- the Lok Sabha and the
Rajya Sabha - parliamentary form of Government in India is fast becoming a
Government not by debate and discussion in the true sense of the term but a Government
by speeches or, more appropriately, a government by “bhashans”. There is
less and less of orderly give and take. Even accepted norms of conduct and
parliamentary niceties patiently sought to be promoted by Nehru -- have fallen
by the wayside.
Most discussions in the Lok Sabha
and with speeches from the two sides with little of the cut and thrust of a
vigorous debate, except on rare occasions. Nehru graciously yielded whenever
any Opposition member sought to interrupt him in the course of his reply to a
debate to elicit a clarification or information. No MP of the ruling party was
permitted, much less encouraged, by Nehru, who spent long hours in the House,
to heckle or shout down Opposition members. Nothing of the kind happens any
more, especially where the Prime Minister is concerned. Mrs Gandhi appears less
and less inclined to be interrupted to offer explanations or clarifications as
at her Press conferences. (Remember, Mrs Gandhi, at her Press conferences,
allows one question one person to give an opportunity to the largest number of
newsmen. This procedure, however, bars alert and probing newsmen from following
up with searching supplementaries.) The “halla” (shouting) groups Congress-I
members make things easier for Mrs Gandhi, even before she has time to say “no”.
Parliament and through it the
country stand to gain in any give and take in a debate. The MPs themselves
benefit, as in the recent stage case involving Prof Madhu Dandwate and Mr Rajiv
Gandhi at one stage and Mr Indrajit Gupta and Mr Rajiv Gandhi at another in the
Lok Sabha discussion on Punjab. Both Prof Dandwate and Mr Gupta gracefully
yielded to Mr Rajiv Gandhi when the latter sought an opportunity to clarify
that he had never described Bhindranwale as a religious leader and had, in
fact, strongly criticised him. Dandwate and Mr Gupta added to their
parliamentary stature by upholding the best parliamentary norm and yielding to
Mr Gandhi. And Rajiv Gandhi, for his part, not only set the record straight but
impressed one and all with his unsuspected ability to cross swords with
seasoned parliamentarians tactfully ---reminding many Parliament watchers of
his father, the late Feroze Gandhi, one of free India’s most effective
parliamentarians. Interestingly, Mr. Rajiv Gandhi, who has a rich voice like
his father’s, sits close to where Feroze Gandhi adorned the non-official
benches.
Alas, the Opposition is even more at
fault. It often fails to play its role and, in the bargain, makes things easier
for the Treasury benches. Nothing illustrates this more than the debate on the
scandalous and painful happenings in Kashmir. Both Mr George Fernandez, Janata,
and Mr Ram Jethmalani, Bharatiya Janata Party, made powerful speeches and
blasted both the Centre and the Governor for the havoc played in Srinagar.
Unfortunately, however, both were missing when the new Home Minister, Mr P.V.
Narasimha Rao, wound up the discussion even if he did so late in the evening in
a debate which seemed to go on interminably. With what result? Mr Narasimha Rao
was able to get away with blue murder on some basic issues through a slick
impressive presentation. In fact, Mr Narasimha Rao was even able to say that
the Opposition had little interest in principles. Said he: “Mr Nar Bahadur
Bhandari, Congress- I Chief Minister in Sikkim, was dismissed. But he went
unwept and unhonoured”. None from the Opposition challenged his tongue-in-the-cheek
statement.
That, however, is only one bit. The
Opposition has been behaving astonishingly even otherwise against its own
interest. It has, at least, twice in the current session demanded suspension of
the Question Hour. Mercifully, the Speaker, Mr Bal Ram Jakhar, overruled the
demand. Clearly, the Opposition wanted to emphasize the importance it gave to
the Kashmir developments in proposing a virtual adjournment motion on the
opening day. But in doing so they allowed their better judgment to run away
with their anger over the happenings --- and their desire to demonstrate their
support for Dr Farooq Abdullah. The Question Hour is in
many ways the most important hour for the Opposition and the back-benchers on
both sides of the House and has even been described by some experts as the “sacred
hour”. The Government under the Constitution, as we all know, is responsible to
Parliament. The Question Hour translates this to reality in practice and
ensures the Government’s accountability. It has also been described as the
hyphen that links Parliament to the Government.
Undoubtedly, the Question Hour is
the most powerful instrument available to the Opposition and, indeed, to all
private members belonging to the ruling party. It enshrines Parliament’s right
to know and through it the people’s right to information. The Question Hour in
its present form is unique and is practised at present only in Britain and
India. It is a part of the daily sittings of the House. Yet it is set apart as
an hour itself because Parliament’s first prerogative is to get information. It
is held from 11 to 12 noon and precedes the “zero hour” -- or what is called
the Public Business in Commons. Since the Question Hour entitles the private
members to put questions on anything which comes within the framework of
Government or national activities, the rules of the House ensure that the
Government does not find an excuse to avoid questions or to conveniently slip
out of the dock. The rules provide that there “shall’ be a Question Hour. In
Britain, too, it comes right at the beginning.
The Question Hour serves two other
purposes. It provides back-benchers with an opportunity to probe the
intelligence and honesty of senior Ministers, even the Prime Minister. It is an
occasion which all members may enjoy and benefit from. There is likely to be
something for everyone without having to listen to long speeches. It also needs
to be remembered that a Minster personally handles very few of the day-to-day
decisions which are taken by his civil servants in his name. These decisions
are, of course, made in a way which the official thinks conforms to ministerial
policy. A question about one of these decisions brings the case on to the
Minister’s desk. The decision may have been taken at quite a low level in the
department. It now is looked at by the senior members of the department -- the
Secretary as well as the Minister. But the fact that the Minister has to give
the answer in a full House and to be prepared for supplementaries helps in
keeping him on his toes.
The crucial importance of the right
to information is not adequately appreciated. The right to information carries
the right to question and, by implication, to control and direct. An interesting story comes to mind
and deserves to be retold. Winston Churchill is said to have asked Lord
Mountbatten only one question when the latter sought his advice about whether
or not he should accept Governor-Generalship of India following independence: “Would
you have the right to information?” When Mountbatten replied yes, Churchill
said; “Fine. Go ahead.” India’s President enjoys the same right. Alas, however,
it has seldom been exercised. Rajen Babu, India’s first President, is known to
have exercised it. But he ceased to do so when he discovered that it was
beginning to sour his relations with Nehru. Mr B.D. Jatti, as Acting President,
exercised it in 1978 and created a sensation and a major problem for the Janata
Government which then wanted him to sign an ordinance to dismiss nine State
Governments.
Parliament’s right to information
has enabled members over the years to bring to light through questions some
sensational scandals in Government’s functioning. Prominent among these have
been the Jeep scandal, the Mundhra affair which led to the resignation of T.T.
Krishnamachari as Finance Minister, the Serajuddin case which led to the exit
of K.D. Malaviya from the Cabinet, the Tulmohan Ram affair and, lately, the Kuo
oil deal. During the British regime, S. Satyamurthi of the Congress Party, for
instance, became a terror through his probing questions. All in all, both the
Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha may not have the power to bend or break the Government,
especially where it has a two-thirds majority. But it has the power to
influence the Government by exposing its weaknesses and acts of omission and
commission. This is vital if one remembers that the ultimate power in our
democratic system rests with the people through the ballot box. Parliament has a key role. But this role needs to be fully
grasped and exploited.---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature
Alliance)
|
|
Providing Jobs: IS GOVT REALLY SERIOUS?, By Dhurjati Mukherjee, 25 October 2023 |
|
|
Open Forum
New Delhi, 25 October
2023
Providing Jobs
IS GOVT REALLY SERIOUS?
By Dhurjati Mukherjee
It was indeed encouraging to hear that India’s impetus in
the tech and digit manufacturing sector will create as many as 50 lakh jobs in
the next three years. This was pointed out by Minister of State for IT and Electronics
Rajeev Chandrasekhar, at the Right to Excellence Tech Summit 2023, held last
month by The Times of India group. Dealing with the success of ‘Made in India’
programmes, he referred to the iPhone 15 unit and the Micron ground-breaking
$2.8 billion semiconductor plant in Gujarat.
“We are one of the fastest growing digital economies in the
world and are encouraging companies to move supply chains to India,” he said
and added the target is to hit $300 billion turnover in electronics by
2025.Companies such as Apple, Micron and others are looking for trustworthy
partners and economies, he exuberated confidence. However, while it can’t be
denied that the country has an edge in the tech sector, it is a fact that huge,
automated plants cannot solve the problem of unemployment, as these are
not in a position to provide jobs as per the increasing requirement.
With State elections being announced and political parties
announcing list of candidates, the Congress and members of INDIA bloc are focussing
on unemployment in a big way. In fact, joblessness is a critical issue that
continues to challenge the economic landscape of India. As one of the world’s
most populous nations with a diverse workforce, fluctuations in the
unemployment rate have far-reaching implications for the country’s growth and
development. The question arises what is the current unemployment rate in
India? Will the term ‘jobless growth’, which we have been hearing for quite a
few years, continue and for how long? When will women become a significant part
of the workforce?
Though the latest data indicates a glimmer of hope, as
India’s unemployment rate has recently declined. According to the National
Sample Survey (NSSO), the unemployment rate for individuals aged 15 years and
above in urban areas decreased to 6.8 percent during January-March 2023 from
8.2 percent a year ago, there is no need to be complacent. According to
the recent Bloomberg report that references data from the Centre for
Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) for July, the overall unemployment rate
in India was 7.95 percent as of July this year and has been calculated at 8.44
percent in August. Thus, all talk of the economy strengthening has not been
reflected in the creation of jobs.
This apart, the recent weather patterns across the country
have brought about significant changes in economic conditions. Given that rainfall
has covered large parts of India, impacting nearly half of the agricultural
land, expectations of higher farm production have risen. It is expected that
this development has the potential to contribute to the overall economic
growth. However, despite the boost in the agricultural sector due to improved
rains, there has been a notable drop in demand for labour from the
non-agricultural sector in rural areas during July.
As a result, the number of rural labourers seeking
employment has decreased, leading to a decline in the rural employment rate.
The labour force in rural India experienced a reduction of approximately five
million individuals. This decline was also witnessed in urban areas, indicating
a broader economic weakness that demands attention. These changing trends in
labour demand and employment rates call for thoughtful policy measures to
address the prevailing economic challenges and ensure sustainable growth both in
rural and urban areas.
According to a recent study by Azim Premji University’s
State of Working India, employment related data show that the resilience of the
job market, particularly for women and young graduates, has lagged compared to
the growth of the overall economy. The unemployment rate in 2021-22 was just
6.6 percent, which was just two percentage points lower than the same in
2019-20. However, an analysis by the SWI report revealed a structural
deterioration in the nature of women’s employment, which has largely been driven
by self-employment, particularly in the category of unpaid work.
Therefore, it may be concluded that the job market for
women hasworsened, and this trend has continued till the end-2022. The monthly
earnings are higher than both 2019-20 and 2020-21. But these earnings of Rs
12.089 in 2021-22 was lower by 2 percent than the same in 2017-18, the year the
government began to present annual employment data. It is thus not surprising
that political parties are rushing to tailor fiscal policies to provide monthly
income support to women in different States. Experts are unanimous in stating
that India’s transformation in the job market has lagged the growth in
GDP.
Though the thrust on manufacturing may yield dividends for
the economy, job creation may be a far cry. There has to be some special effort
to identify the labour-intensive sectors and give special benefits considering
the number of labour/employees they recruit. In fact, there needs to be a
comprehensive plan with incentives, and this must be formulated by the Centre
and sent to all the States for implementation.
The other important thing is the need to fill up vacancies
of teachers in schools and colleges spread across the country. Most States are
financially distressed and, as such, do not want to fill up the vacant posts.
Not just in education and health, in others as well like municipalities, village
health centres and hospitals and even panchayats, there are huge vacancies in
most States. Providing them jobs would surely bring down the unemployment rate.
Another important area is with regard to MGNREGS where
funds provided are hardly capable of providing employment for 35 days or so
with the current wage prevailing in the respective States. Most State
governments pay less than the minimum wage rate and try to provide employment
for 40-45 days whereas the scheme is destined to generate employment for 100
days a year. When governments can beautify cities, build huge convention
centres, modernise airports, should not allocation for this programme be
enhanced on a priority basis?
There have also been suggestions by a large section of
economists and developmental experts on starting an urban employment scheme to
bridge the huge gap here. Such a scheme would augur well as those given say 50
or 60 days of assured employment could be gainfully used in various areas – be
it in the municipalities, electricity boards or in government offices. Though
the ruling dispensation is yet to react to this proposal, it is necessary that
a concentrated effort be made to put pressure on the government.
Providing employment to our increasing workforce is crucial
for socio-economic and political stability. Unless the young generation is
gainfully engaged, there would be repercussions that may destabilise the social
order. This sadly may happen and worse the political leadership is taking
advantage of it. With Opposition parties harping on joblessness and hollow
promises of the BJP at Centre during the upcoming assembly polls, it would be
worthwhile to see what priority is given to it by those who come to power.
Enough of talk and little action. ---INFA
(Copyright, India News & Feature
Alliance)
|
|
|
More...
-
Cash-for-Vote Scam: JILTED LOVE, HENRY & POWER OF GREED, By Poonam I Kaushish, 24 October 2023
-
High MSP More Populist: FEWER FARMERS BENEFIT!, By Shivaji Sarkar, 23 October 2023
-
‘Cash For Query’ Scam: TMC MP DEFIANT, PARTY SILENT, By Insaf, 21 October 2023
-
Israel-Hamas War: HOW THE WORLD REACTS, By Dr D.K. Giri, 20 October 2023
| << Start < Previous 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Next > End >>
| Results 154 - 162 of 5980 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|